Image
Kongresshuset i USA
Breadcrumb

Politicians can gain voter support by introducing bills destined to fail

Published

American voters respond more favorably to politicians who introduce bills in Congress, even when those bills have no chance of becoming law. That is the finding of a study involving researchers from the University of Gothenburg and other institutions.

An increasing number of bills are being introduced in the U.S. Congress, while a declining proportion receive a vote. During the 2023–2024 congressional term, 19,315 bills were introduced, but only 4 percent received a vote.

The researchers examined how American voters respond to what is known as symbolic legislation – bills introduced by members of Congress despite knowing they have insufficient support to become law.

“Voters appreciate it when politicians take action, even if their efforts do not lead to any concrete policy change,” says Nicole Huffman, a postdoctoral researcher in political science at the University of Gothenburg and one of the study’s authors.

Survey experiment

The study is based on a survey experiment involving 3,351 participants, conducted in the United States in 2023.

Participants were asked to imagine a hypothetical member of Congress from their preferred political party who shared their views on an issue they considered very important. They were then randomly assigned to one of two groups, each presented with a different scenario. In both scenarios, a bill addressing the issue lacked sufficient support in Congress to become law. The only difference was whether the politician chose to introduce the bill or decided not to.

“We converted participants’ ratings to a scale from 0 to 100. When the politician chose not to introduce the bill, the average favorability rating was 40. When the bill was introduced, the rating rose to 61,” says Nicole Huffman.

Stronger effect among highly educated voters – positive across party lines

Participants’ willingness to vote for the politician in the next election was also affected. The estimated probability of voting for the politician was 64 percent when the bill was introduced, compared with 42 percent when the politician chose not to introduce it.

The researchers also examined whether education level and party affiliation influenced support for the politician.

“Highly educated participants responded particularly favorably when the politician introduced a bill despite knowing it lacked sufficient support. The positive effect was found among Democrats, Republicans, and political independents alike,” says Nicole Huffman.

The researchers emphasize that the findings apply to voters who already agreed with the politician on an issue they considered important. Further research is needed to determine how voters respond when they disagree with a politician’s position.

“Our findings show that even bills that never become law can have political significance. They can influence how voters view their elected representatives,” says Nicole Huffman.

More information

Nicole Huffman conducted the research as a doctoral student at Stony Brook University in the United States before becoming a postdoctoral researcher at the University of Gothenburg. They coauthored the article with John V. Kane, Clinical Associate Professor at the Center for Global Affairs at New York University, and David L. Stack, Associate College Lecturer at Cleveland State University in Ohio.

Reference: Huffman, N., Kane, J. V., & Stack, D. L. (2026). Worth a try? The electoral consequences of symbolic legislation. Research & Politics.