Till sidans topp

Sidansvarig: Webbredaktion
Sidan uppdaterades: 2012-09-11 15:12

Tipsa en vän

Medical, Ethical, and Leg… - Göteborgs universitet Till startsida
Till innehåll Läs mer om hur kakor används på gu.se

Medical, Ethical, and Legal Risks in Forensic Age Assessment Procedures in Current Swedish Asylum Processes Involving Unaccompanied Minors

Konferensbidrag (offentliggjort, men ej förlagsutgivet)
Författare Josephine T. V. Greenbrook
Henry Ascher
Publicerad i Program and proceedings of the Oxford Global Health & Bioethics International Conference in Oxford, United Kingdom, July 1-2, 2019 (oral presentations)
Publiceringsår 2019
Publicerad vid Institutionen för medicin, avdelningen för samhällsmedicin och folkhälsa
Institutionen för sociologi och arbetsvetenskap
Institutionen för medicin
Institutionen för kliniska vetenskaper, Avdelningen för pediatrik
Institutionen för vårdvetenskap och hälsa
Språk en
Ämnesord unaccompanied minors, migration, forensic age assessment, forensic medicine, human rights, convention on the rights of the child, medical ethics, asylum seekers, risk assessment
Ämneskategorier Internationell Migration och Etniska Relationer (IMER), Etik, Sociologi, Juridik, Medicinsk etik, Folkhälsovetenskap, global hälsa, socialmedicin och epidemiologi, Rättsmedicin


There is a broad consensus surrounding the acutely vulnerable plight of asylum-seeking unaccompanied children, transcending international policy, academic literature, and expert opinion in both medicine and jurisprudence. Children migrating alone are at extreme risk of exposure to violence, exploitation, and poor health, and thus require extensive social, medical, and legal support, both during migration, and post migration whilst waiting for their asylum claims to be processed. The Swedish government has voiced intent to protect the human right to asylum in Europe, accenting that processes must be solidarity-based, legally certain, sustainable, efficient, and humane in facilitating reliable assessments protecting the rights of asylum-seekers. The present study explores current debate surrounding the deficient scientific reliability of recently introduced two step forensic age assessment procedures in Swedish asylum processes involving unaccompanied minors, and discusses the stakes involved from a medical, ethical, and legal perspective. The analysis included current policy documents, health professions unions' statements and reports, expert and media debate, and United Nations committee reports. Although the vast majority of forensic age assessment conducted thus far in Sweden have assessed biological age as 18 or above, expert consensus has decried methods applied as being unable to withstand the test of scientific scrutiny. Concerns surrounding the procedures’ medically unjustifiable and highly unethical nature, as well as the misuse of the medical profession' authority, expertise, and skill in forwarding political agendas have been noted. Furthermore, in disregarding the precautionary principle by default, current reductionist and pseudoscientific forensic methods risk facilitating the bypassing of laws intended to protect the human rights of children at their most vulnerable. These highly consequential forensic age assessments must yield results greater than chance, as the aftermath of failures are neither humane, sustainable, or legally certain. Flawed results can impede children from accessing foundational human rights, such as the right to health, to thrive, and to meet their full potential, raising resounding medical, ethical, and legal concerns. The social sciences must contribute with expertise and actively engage in this debate, and work toward developing and establishing a thorough and holistic age assessment process, including biomedical aspects such as growth curves, x-rays, and adding psychosocial components such as recollection of childhood memories, psychosocial maturity, along with reports from adults in the children’s social networks (such as teachers, social workers, and others) on how the assessed child handled everyday life.

Sidansvarig: Webbredaktion|Sidan uppdaterades: 2012-09-11

På Göteborgs universitet använder vi kakor (cookies) för att webbplatsen ska fungera på ett bra sätt för dig. Genom att surfa vidare godkänner du att vi använder kakor.  Vad är kakor?