Better military technology does not lead to shorter wars
News: Mar 16, 2010
It is generally assumed that military technology that is offensive rather than defensive in nature leads to shorter wars. Yet, a new doctoral thesis from the University of Gothenburg shows that this assumption is not correct.
For long, researchers have thought that offensive military technology, such as armoured cars and attack jets, makes it easier to shorten the duration of a war. It is also generally perceived that when the offensive technology is more effective than the defensive technology, it is more advantageous to start a war.
’While this may be seen in some wars where the attacker is clearly superior, it is not true on average. This means that the improved military technology has not resulted in any advantages for the attacking force, at least not in terms of war duration,’ says Marco Nilsson, who recently earned his PhD from the Department of Political Science at the University of Gothenburg.
To investigate the effect of offensive technology on war duration, Nilsson statistically analysed all wars in the state system from 1817 to 1992. Interestingly, he did not find any effect at all.
’I found that, in reality, the potential advantages of attack-oriented technology is limited by for example terrain, technological development, training of military personnel, climate, weather and norms. Due to these limitations, attack-oriented technology normally does not allow a state to run over an enemy as easily as expected. Unless the attacked country collapses right away, the duration of most wars is decided at the negotiation table,’ says Nilsson.
If two fighting countries could sit down at the negotiation table and base their demands only on military capacity, it would be easy for them to reach a mutually acceptable solution to their armed conflict – the stronger would make high demands and the weaker would accept them. Yet, this hardly ever happens in real life. Nilsson’s study of four different wars (the Winter War 1939, the Continuation War 1941-1943, the Iran-Iraq War 1980-1988 and the war between India and Pakistan 1965) shows that states do not always base their demands at the negotiation table on military capacity.
’A major problem arises when a state has offensive expectations that do not match what is actually seen on the battlefield. These seemingly unrealistic expectations can for example be a result of a conviction that God will step in and influence the outcome of a war. Another reason may be that a country for some reason expects its offensive ability to soon improve,’ says Nilsson.
Unfortunately, some states start wars expecting their attack-oriented technology to warrant quick success. Therefore, too much confidence in offensive technology may increase the likelihood of new wars and speed up arms racing, all due to a misunderstanding among decision makers. A better understanding of the potentials and limitations of military technology could lead to a world where many drawn-out and costly wars are avoided.
Title of the doctoral thesis: WAR AND UNREASON. Bounded Learning Theory.
Author: Marco Nilsson, tel. +46 (0)762 24 12 31 (home), +46 (0)31 786 43 18(work)
E-link: https://gupea.ub.gu.se/dspace/handle/2077/21522
E-mail: marco.nilsson@pol.gu.se
Faculty opponent: Magnus Öberg, Senior Lecturer, Uppsala University
The thesis was publicly defended on Friday 12 March.
The thesis can also be ordered at: marco.nilsson@pol.gu.se
News
Exercise in early twenties may lower risk of osteoporosi
[9 Feb 2012] Physical exercise in the early twenties improves bone development and may reduce the risk of fractures later in life, reveals a study of more than 800 Swedish men carried out at the Sahlgrenska Academy.
Versions of Young Designers' Vision
[9 Feb 2012] In a time of increasing individual focus a group of young Swedish designers present their vision: collectivity and sharing. The visual communication of the project is inspired by surrealism, football and choirs. Stockholm Furniture & Light Fair 2012 is the place where it all happens.
Combined oral contraceptive pill helps painful periods
[26 Jan 2012] A large Scandinavian study that has been running for 30 years has finally provided convincing evidence that the combined oral contraceptive pill does, indeed, alleviate the symptoms of painful menstrual periods. The research is published in Europe´s leading reproductive medicine journal Human Reproduction.
TEDxTalk: Maria Sundin - Water - a necessity for life on Earth and other Planets
[17 Jan 2012] Why is there water on earth? Life is highly connected to liquid water so the question arises, are there other worlds like ours?
Contact Information
Henrik Axlid, Press Officer
PO Box 100, 405 30 Gothenburg, Sweden
Visiting Address:
Vasaparken
Phone:
+46 (0)31-786 20 21
+46 (0)734-04 20 21